Shouting Fire in a Crowded Theater~by KY Born

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for redress of grievances”.-First Amendment of the United States Constitution

Isn’t the First Amendment great?  I have no desire to see it go away. However, like any idea, it can be corrupted just as it is currently being subtly corrupted by antis now.

It was the idea that the First Amendment was some sort of carte blanche that led to the Supreme Court ruling in 1919 known as Schenck v. United States where Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes tried to give some clarity to what limits could constitutionally be placed by the government on personal expression in order to protect not only the rights of one person, but the rights of all citizens from the actions of one to impede their freedoms. I have purposefully bolded “by the government” because many people seem to think that private entities like Facebook, Twitter, Target or private citizens’ blogs have some obligation to allow whoever and whatever to be published on their websites, or posted on their private property as part of the First Amendment. This simply isn’t true. Perhaps the most famous quote to come from this ruling is, “The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic.”

The problem comes that antis are no longer just committing occasional violations or giant violations that make the news, but are committing ever-increasing and bolder violations while still remaining under most people’s radar. When challenged, they wrap themselves in the First Amendment because many local, state and federal officials hesitate to approach the line between “free speech” and “shouting fire.”

We all know about the big events that are used to terrorize women away from clinics so I want to talk about the smaller violations that are often overlooked, but still are used to terrorize women seeking healthcare. The line is crossed more easily than ever due to YouTube and access to internet postings that feature antis screaming that people are murderers, or post their picture and personal information all over the Internet.

Did you know in some locations antis erect ladders that totally block public sidewalks, forcing anybody who needs to use the sidewalks to access the clinic, or simply to pass through, to step around them? They do this so they can peer over fences to film people entering a medical facility, write down license plates and directly harass patients. This You Tube video was taken in Jackson, Mississippi, but happens at other clinics around the country every day.

The even more subtle, which I have witnessed myself, is the slow walking back and forth across driveway entrances, causing cars to slam on brakes in the middle of busy roads and potentially causing accidents. In some communities, the response from public officials is to call it the First Amendment and do nothing to stop it.

Another subtle way that anti organizations intimidate people and obstruct their right to terminate a pregnancy is through Crisis Pregnancy Centers, or similarly called organizations, that try to trick women out of getting abortions. Much has been written about them other places so I won’t repeat it other than to give people this advice about anyplace that claims to provide medical care:  If they do not give you a Notice of Privacy Practices (more commonly known as the HIPAA form) demand all of your personal information, any copies made and walk out. They are not a legitimate health care provider.

I don’t believe we need a lot more new laws, but we need the current laws enforced. None of this would be tolerated anywhere except outside a medical facility that provides abortion services, or at the homes of those who work there.

I guess this is my main point. I use this analogy frequently and I have self-named it the “ex-boyfriend rule.”  If you have already heard me say this feel free to skip over it, but my point is that if one of my ex-boyfriends chose to engage in any of above-mentioned actions under the guise of freedom of speech or religion, they would be served with a restraining order and likely criminal charges. If they and their gathered group of friends who also believe as they do, follow me, surround me on a public sidewalk, prevent me from walking on a public sidewalk, turning into a private driveway, erected a ladder on a public sidewalk to view my activities over a fence on private property, or provided information to people intent on causing me harm, they all would be subjected to restraining orders or criminal charges.

Garbage like this makes me wonder if the end of abortion will not come about from dramatic events like the overturning of Roe or a series of clinic bombings, but the slow, steady and repeated crossing of lines under the guise of “free speech” that is nothing more than shouting fire in a crowded theater.

I took the right to abortion for granted for years.

I will not make this mistake again. I hope you won’t either.


5 thoughts on “Shouting Fire in a Crowded Theater~by KY Born

  1. I appreciate the information provided in this blog. I never pictured myself having to get involved with anything like this. I’ve always said it’s a woman’s choice and for those that say no they never could, you don’t know until in that situation. My 19 year old daughter left home very oddly this summer, went out of state, we didn’t hear a lot from her, didn’t really know where she was, it was all way out of character for her. She came home last week and came in my office upset, she had been sick and was going to the Dr. I had to ask her the question are you pregnant. She burst into tears and said there is a reason I left Kentucky this summer, I was raped at Western. I had gone to a party to drive friends home and must have set my drink down and I don’t remember anything but waking up. She has blocked this out, I can’t get many details from her, she refuses counseling. I know that there is no way she could have it, she more than likely would take her own life if she had to carry it. She is a bright outgoing girl, has an academic scholarship and athletic scholarship. She is going into Nursing and in her second year of school. So for all the people out there calling baby killers..well if I don’t help her I will lose my baby. Life isn’t fair and no one asked for this. We both belong to a church and believe very deeply in God. Bless you all for the information and I promise to pay it forward at some point so someone else can have freedom of choice.

    • Thank you so much for sharing your story with us. It means a lot to us that our blog can help you and her in this difficult time. I think a lot of people just don’t know what they would do if faced with your situation. I’m so grateful you are there for your daughter. With the distance of time, she may consent to counseling. My heart is breaking for both of you, but I am so glad we were able to help in some small way.

    • Thank you so much for sharing your story. I will keep you and your daughter close in thought. I want to make sure you’re aware that even if your daughter isn’t ready for counseling at this time, Kentucky’s rape crisis centers also serve people like you–secondary survivors. What happened to your daughter has certainly impacted you too, and it’s important that you take care of yourself so that you can continue to support her. if you’re in the Louisville area, The Center for Women and Families is the rape crisis center for that area, and they can be reached 24/7 at 502.581.7222. if you’re in another part of the state, or in another state, you can get to your local RCC by calling RAINN’s hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE. RAINN’s website has some good resources for secondary survivors as well. Sending love to you and your family.

      • Thank you for your thoughts they are greatly needed. Tomorrow will be a tough day but I think I am a little better prepared with the information in this blog. I may reach out to the crisis line, I do need help to know the best way to help her.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s